You’ll savor the area’s best pizza with all your favorite toppings

At Fat Boys' Pizzeria in Phelps, NY, we’ve got delicious, homemade food your whole family will enjoy at reasonable prices. Open 7 days a week, you’ll be happy you called us or stopped by for lunch or dinner!

View Menu
Online Ordering Now Available Order Online

About Fat Boys' Pizzeria

Now under new ownership, Fat Boys' Pizzeria in Phelps, NY, is family-owned and proud to serve satisfied customers throughout Ontario County, including Phelps, Oak Corners and Clifton Springs.

You’ll savor the area’s best pizza with all your favorite toppings (including specialty pizzas like our Philly Cheese Steak and Hawaiian); finger-licking wings in eight bold flavors; subs; appetizers, from garlic knots to onion rings; the amazing Fat Boys' Pizzeria burger and other platters; calzones and pasta; and salads made fresh every day.

And don’t forget dessert, including Xangos – cheesecake wrapped in a tortilla, fried and rolled in cinnamon sugar.

Pizza Delivery
pizza icon

Free Delivery

Free delivery with $10 minimum order. Call for specific delivery area.

pizza icon

Order Online

Hungry for something great? Well, you’ve come to the right place. Check out Fat Boys' Pizzeria's menu and place your order online or by phone.

Order Online
pizza icon

25% off order

Receive 25% off your first order when you order online today!

Ask About our Catering

Contact Us